Feedback: What a Critique Group can Do for Your Story–And It’s MORE than You think!

Our local critique group met yesterday and it was an exciting meeting. Almost everyone sent the first chapter of a new project. That’s exciting. It means that the group is healthy, that we are collectively working hard on our stories.

Critiquing Manuscripts

checklistI learn almost as much when I critique manuscripts, as when I get a critique. Because I come to a story with a fresh eye, I can see the strengths and weaknesses in ways that the author can’t. It helps me to understand the role of a reader better.

Two things strike me: First, the author must put it on the page. When I ask for clarification on something, the author ALWAYS launches into an explanation. In other words, in her mind, it’s perfectly clear. The problem is that it didn’t get onto the page.

Second, our work is iterative. That is, we do a version, and then tweak, and then repeat and repeat and repeat. With each revision, the story is closer to perfect. We close the gap on communicating clearly and with emotion. One author’s plot and characterization were great except it lacked emotion. Can you layer that in later? Of course. Anything can be layered in later. That’s the revision process.

First Drafts. But this time, the main thing I said was, “Keep going!” These were mostly the first chapter of a new project and at this fragile moment of the writing process, the writer mostly needs encouragement to continue. For one writer, this is especially important because this was the first chapter of the very first novel she has ever attempted. At that point, well, all you can do is turn cheerleader. “Go! Go! Go!”

Getting Critiqued

When it was time for comments to turn to my own story, I felt the familiar stomach pinch that says, “Please love me.” But that quickly turned into the wise and mature response (Ahem!), “Please tell me the truth.”

It seems I have a major plot problem in the story. Two people noticed it and others agreed. And, well, OK, I sorta agree. Ok. I do agree.

And the revision won’t be that hard or that major when I sit down to do it.

In fact, I’m excited. The story pleased me, but I knew I was still in the early phases of revision. The critique groups comments were MORE than I ever hoped for. Exactly what I needed.

Why do we ever fear feedback? Ours is a business of communication. Ideas, characters, images–things in my head should be reproduced in the reader’s head EXACTLY, through the medium of words written on a page. Duh! I need to check that the communication actually happened. And when it’s not passed on EXACTLY, I need to tweak.

Thanks, critique group! You’re the best!

4 thoughts on “0

  1. Great post! I’m always anxious about critiques too, and my initial thought is me hoping for perfection which is silly not to mention totally unrealistic. Your group sounds wonderful! I really need to find one.

  2. Dana:
    Yeah, I always want them to say I’m perfect. Sigh. But they never do. And, bless their hearts, they are always right.
    It’s worth a search to find a good group.

  3. Wonderful post, Darcy! Critiques are an essential part of the writing process. After you’ve reworked your story so many times, it can be hard to see. You need that “fresh eye.” I find feedback on the title to also be extremely useful. How do you know when you actually have a great title? People are picking up your material because they say, “What a great title, let me take a look at that.” Now, of course we go back to we want the material to be, as great as it can be, but a great title will automatically catch someone’s interest and they want to take a look at it.

Comments are closed.

Previous post 5 Small–But Vital–Tasks for Off Days: #4 is the Worst
Next post Endangered Species Day: Book Trailer